Choose selectively from the best available

• Select the best red port if choosing kebab for starters
• Selectively choose the best from what's available
• Choose the best
• Selfishly, just take the best bits
• Be very selective
• Choose only the evidence that fits a predetermined argument
• Select the best and leave the rest
• Select the best

Wiktionary Word definitions in Wiktionary
vb. (alternative spelling of cherry-pick English)