Win the Home Run Derby, e.g

• Bat for a higher average than
• Score more runs than
• Do better at the plate
• Batted better than
• Do better than at bat
• Bested at the plate
• Have a higher batting average than
• Best at the plate

Wiktionary Word definitions in Wiktionary
vb. To hit something better or further than another, especially to score better in a game involving hitting a ball with a bat.