Best in an annual Nathan's contest, say

• Beat at dinner
• Surpass at the dinner table
• Best at a buffet, say
• Beat in a pie contest, say
• Beat at a Nathan's hot dog contest, say
• Surpass in a hot dog contest
• Show up at the dinner table?
• Beat in a hot dog competition
• Win a contest for trenchermen

Wiktionary Word definitions in Wiktionary
vb. (context transitive English) To eat more than.