Visited Davy Jones's locker

• Put in the cup, as a golf ball
• Behaved like a lead balloon?
• Went like the Titanic
• Suffered the same fate as the Titanic
• Putted into the hole
• Foundered
• Went to the bottom of the ocean
• Headed to bed?

Wiktionary Word definitions in Wiktionary
vb. (en-simple past of: sink )